By Mitch Albom at freep.com, titled:
Hey, you senators: Thanks for nothing
A few parting words for the senators who squashed the auto rescue
I've pulled a few quotes and added my responses.
Do you want to watch us drown? Is that it? Do want to see the last gurgle of economic air spit from our lips?
If we're talking about the UAW, then yes.
Suddenly, the worker is the problem? Suddenly, unless union members, overnight, drastically slash their wages with a hard deadline, you pull the plug on an industry?
No, the union is the problem. The "plug" is not government's to pull. If the automakers can't stand on their own four wheels, it's their problem.
Suddenly, Detroit is the symbol of economic dysfunction? Are you kidding? Have you looked in the mirror lately, Washington?
Touche', but I'm not defending Washington. I'm saying it is not Washington's job to feed a bloated beast with taxpayer's money. You seem to think it is.
In a world where banks hemorrhaged trillions in a high-priced gamble called credit derivative swaps that you failed to regulate, how on earth do we need to be punished? In a bailout era where you shoveled billions, with no demands, to banks and financial firms — who created the problem in the first place
Not true. It was government regulation by Democrats that caused the problem. Those firms were doing exactly what the government forced them to do. I know that 52% of this country doesn't know that, but it's true.
— why do need to be schooled on how to run a business?
Makes no sense. Apparently, the Big Three do need to learn some lessons, like how to stand up to the UAW for starters. How to make reasonably priced cars that are still running great at 150,000 miles is another. How to service and repair them without gouging their customers would be a third.
At least in the auto industry, if folks don’t like what you make, they don’t have to buy it.
True. That's why Detroit has been in a downhill slide for 30 years. And now, after decades of screwing the American consumer to the point that the free market is killing you, you want the taxpayer to keep Detroit afloat, while the UAW refuses man the pumps. Screw Detroit, and screw the UAW.
Corker, you’ve got Nissan there and Volkswagen coming. Shelby, you’ve got Hyundai, Honda, Mercedes-Benz and Toyota. Oh, don’t kid yourself. They didn’t come because you earned their business, a subject on which you enjoy lecturing the Detroit Big Three. No, they came because you threw billions in state tax breaks to lure them.
Hmm. Tax breaks bringing big businesses and jobs..... hmmmm. But there's a night-and-day difference between offering a tax discount at the front end and and a bailout near the end. Not charging tax isn't a handout. In the end the state makes more tax revenue, that's wise stewardship and good economic sense. A bailout check to prolong a failing industry is not.
At our nation’s most uncertain hour, you stood ready to plunge tens of thousands of families into oblivion. Push them onto public payrolls, unemployment, no health insurance. And you were willing to put our nation’s security at risk — by squashing the American manufacturing we most rely on in times of war.
Blah, blah, blah. Those UAW families make double or triple what mine does, and have done so for decades. My heart bleeds for the poor UAW- not. Yes, non-union suppliers will get hurt, too. It's not the taxpayer's job. And that old saw about the automakers being important to National Security hasn't been true for 40 years. Give it up.
And why? So you could stand on some phony principle? Crush a union? Play to your base? How is our nation better off today now that you kept $14 billion in the treasury? Are you going to balance the budget with that?
The free market isn't a phony principle, it's how a capitalist country works. Crush a union? I'm good with that. "Playing to your base" is actually called "doing what your constituents want". It's a nearly-forgotten concept in government, I'm not surprised you'd be confused. Frankly, I was surprised to see it myself.
You tried to slam a stake into the chest of this business, and you don’t even realize how close to the nation’s heart you’re coming. Shame on your pettiness. Shame on your hypocrisy. This is how we behave two weeks before Christmas? Honestly. What has become of this country?
I- I- find it hard to- I can't- he played the Christmas card!? Oh woe is America! Where is our charity at this, of all times of year? There are fat UAW workers that have been making double and triple what other workers make for decades in trouble! Oh. My. God.
He's actually saying that because it's Christmas the taxpayers should hand the UAW a pot of gold so they can keep right on doing as they have for decades? Will they be back every December 1st with the same argument? You can bet they will. This needs to stop here.
I repeat my pledge:
We, the undersigned American Taxpayers, pledge that if Ford, Chrysler, or General Motors accepts the taxpayer's money and the United Auto Worker's union does not take a 20% cut in wages, benefits, and pensions, we will not buy a new vehicle from any of those companies as long as the UAW has contracts with them.
Would you sign this?